Home Self Improvement When and How to Change Your Medicare Supplement Plan

When and How to Change Your Medicare Supplement Plan

Health insurance scrabble tiles

Are you getting the most out of your Medicare Supplement plan, or is it time for a change? This decision can significantly impact your healthcare coverage and expenses. 

We understand that navigating the world of healthcare can be daunting, but fear not! In this comprehensive guide, we will break down when and how to change your Medicare Supplement plan, ensuring you make informed choices that suit your evolving needs.

Why Your Medicare Supplement Plan Matters

Your Medicare Supplement plan, also known as Medigap, plays a crucial role in filling the gaps left by Original Medicare (Part A and Part B). This plan can help cover various healthcare costs, such as copayments, deductibles, and coinsurance. That said, as your health and circumstances change, your plan may need to change too.

When Should You Consider Changing Your Medicare Supplement Plan?

Changes in Health Status

Life is unpredictable, and your health can change unexpectedly. So, a change in your health status, be it a new condition or a worsened pre-existing condition, may lead to a reassessment of your Medicare Supplement plan. A plan that worked for you in earlier years may no longer serve its purpose for your current needs.

For example, imagine you initially opted for Medigap when you were in good health and rarely required doctor visits. However, you now have a chronic illness that necessitates frequent specialist consultations and expensive medications. In such a case, your current plan may not be sufficient to cover these new expenses.

Financial Changes

Your financial situation can also influence your decision to change your supplement plan. If you’re experiencing financial difficulties or significant changes in income, you may want to explore more cost-effective options.

For instance, suppose you are about to retire or have recently retired. Your income may be about to decrease substantially. Thus, you may realize that your current Medigap plan does not fit into your current financial status.

Therefore, you should look into changing to a plan with lower monthly premiums. This might mean slightly higher out-of-pocket costs, but it should be worth it in the long run to avoid excessive spending and achieve financial freedom.

Dissatisfaction With Your Current Plan

You may simply be unhappy with your current Medicare Supplement plan. This dissatisfaction could stem from various reasons, such as poor customer service, coverage limitations, or a desire for more benefits.


You may need to review your Medicare Supplement plan if you plan to move to a different state or within the same state. Coverage and costs can vary depending on your location, so what worked in one area may not be as suitable in another.

Imagine you’re retiring and want to move from a high-priced urban area to a more affordable community. The plan you currently have may not be cost-efficient in your new location, as healthcare providers and costs can differ significantly.

How to Change Your Medicare Supplement Plan

Now that you’ve identified the reasons for changing your Medicare Supplement plan, let’s delve into the practical steps for making this transition.

  • Understand Enrollment Periods

Medicare Supplement plans are subject to specific enrollment periods. The most suitable time to change your plan without the risk of underwriting (health questions or medical exams) is during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period. This period typically starts when you’re 65 or older and have enrolled in Medicare Part B. It lasts for six months.

During this window, insurance companies cannot deny you coverage or charge higher premiums based on your health. You will have the freedom to switch to any Medicare Supplement plan available in your area.  

Furthermore, you won’t have to go through a waiting period for preexisting conditions. Now, rather than an insurer temporarily refusing to cover an existing illness, full benefits would start immediately.

  • Research and Compare Plans

MacBook and notebook on a table

Knowledge is power. Take the time to research and compare available Medicare Supplement plans. There are ten standardized plans labeled with letters (e.g., plan F, plan G) across most states. These plans offer different levels of coverage and price points, so it’s essential to understand what each one includes.

Use online tools and resources like the official Medicare website or Medicare plan comparison websites to compare plans side by side. Consider your current and future healthcare needs to determine which plan aligns best with your circumstances.

  • Contact Insurance Companies

Once you’ve identified a new Medicare Supplement plan that suits your needs, get in touch with insurance companies that offer it. Speak with their representatives or agents to clarify any questions you may have. Request written information about the plan’s coverage, costs, and benefits.

  • Review the Application Process

When you decide to change your Medicare Supplement plan, you’ll typically need to complete an application. Understand the application process, and ensure you have all necessary documentation, such as your Medicare card and current Medigap policy information.

  • Enroll in the New Plan

After comparing plans, consulting with insurance companies, and gathering the required documents, it’s time to enroll in your chosen Medicare Supplement plan. Remember to do this during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period to avoid underwriting.

  • Cancel Your Old Plan (if necessary)

Once you’re approved for the new plan, you may need to cancel your old one. Be sure to follow the proper cancellation procedures to avoid any overlap in coverage or unnecessary premium payments.

  • Review Your Prescription Drug Coverage

If you also have a Medicare Part D prescription drug plan, ensure that your new Medigap plan doesn’t affect your drug coverage. Sometimes, a change in Medigap plans may necessitate adjusting your prescription drug coverage for a seamless healthcare experience.


Your Medicare Supplement plan is a critical component of your healthcare coverage, and it should adapt to your changing needs. 

Whether it’s due to changes in health, finances, dissatisfaction, or relocation, it is important to know when and how to change your Medicare Supplement plan. This can help you maintain comprehensive and affordable healthcare coverage.

Remember that the key to a successful transition is thorough research and timely action. Evaluate your options, compare plans, and make the change during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period when underwriting is not a concern. 

By following these steps, you can ensure that your Medicare Supplement plan continues to support your health and financial well-being in the best possible way.

Felicia Wilson


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here